Eleven years ago, seven drama students entered their fourth year at the prestigious Dellecher Classical Conservatory. Now, a decade after the end of that school year, one of those students, Oliver Marks, is being released from prison. Former police detective Colborne has never entirely bought the official version of what happened, and Oliver agrees to finally tell the truth of that year. Or at least a truth.
The highly competitive nature of the school and constantly interacting with each other have made the seven students their own little troupe with defined roles. But a couple of the students have begun resenting their typecasting, and natural born star Richard is on the verge of snapping. Even when Richard is removed from the picture, the fractures in the group widen until the tragic climax.
This is a debut novel from Shakespearean scholar M.L. Rio, and is full of William Shakespeare’s words and ideas. The theater kids often quote (or misquote) Shakespeare’s plays to each other in their dialogue, and sometimes to confused or annoyed outsiders. A basic familiarity with the Bard of Avon will vastly enhance your enjoyment of the story.
The main characters are the kind of “party hearty” kids I did not get on well with in college; their substance abuse is a large factor in how badly their actions go off the rails, and the sexual shenanigans certainly didn’t help. And of course, keeping secrets from the adults on campus who could have solved many of the issues early on makes things even worse. (While I am on content issues, warning for rough language, slut-shaming and domestic abuse.)
Oliver has pressures outside school as well, as his parents are unsupportive of his career goals and one of his sisters has an eating disorder that needs them to redirect their limited financial resources. (Oliver is alas completely unempathetic towards his sister’s problems.) And some of the other students have even worse family situations, one of the reasons they’ve bonded with each other instead.
Once having established that the main characters are not the kind of people who make smart choices, the stage is set for the inevitable spiral into tragedy, mirrored by the plays they’re performing.
The version of the novel I’m reviewing is the audiobook from Macmillan Audio, and read by Robert Petkoff, himself an actor experienced in Shakespearean drama. His voice is well suited to the text (though there were times when I could not distinguish between female characters) and conveyed emotion well.
However, the audiobook experience was sometimes difficult for me. I sometimes missed important words, especially early on, and “rewinding” the CD was trickier than simply turning back pages to recheck lines. On the good side, portions of the book are written in a semi-script style that made it clear who was speaking, very helpful when all the main characters are in the same room.
The physical presentation of the audiobook is barebones, just a box containing plain white sleeves for the ten CDs. There are no liner notes (it would have been both helpful and apropos to provide a dramatis personae), nor a quick bio of Mr. Petkoff.
While this novel has mystery elements, it fits more comfortably into the “contemporary” subgenre. Perhaps that New Adult category I’ve heard of. Recommended to Shakespeare buffs, theater kids and fans of last minute twists.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this audiobook from the publisher to facilitate this review. No other compensation was requested nor offered.
The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction Nov/Dec 2016 edited by C.C. Finlay
The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction started publication in 1949. According to Wikipedia, it was supposed to be a fantasy story version of Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine as it was at the time, classic reprints mixed with new material of a higher literary quality than was common in the pulps of the time. Science fiction was added to expand the possible pool of stories. F&SF has managed to publish fairly regularly ever since, though in recent years it’s bimonthly. It has a reputation for literate fiction.
The cover story is “The Cat Bell” by Esther M. Friesner. Mr. Ferguson is a successful actor in the early Twentieth Century, even having a fine house with servants. One of those servants, Cook, greatly admires Mr. Ferguson. Mr. Ferguson greatly admires cats, and has nineteen of them that Cook must feed every day. One day there are twenty cats, and Cook finds herself in a fairy tale. Content note: Cook suffers from several of the less pleasant “isms” and isn’t afraid to say so.
“The Farmboy” by Albert E. Cowdrey is set on a distant planet being surveyed by a scout ship. The crew has discovered a massive deposit of gold, but even if they had room to take it with them, the government would simply confiscate the wealth, giving nothing to the survey crew. Several of the crew members come up with a scheme to make themselves very rich at the expense of the rest of the crew. But if you can’t spot the sucker at the poker game, it’s probably you…some unpleasant sexism.
“Between Going and Staying” by Lilliam Rivera takes place in a future Mexico even more dominated by the drug cartels. Dolores is a professional mourner using the newest bodysuit technology. She’s been making very good money performing for the wealthy, but this funeral is personal.
There are two book review columns, one by Charles de Lint, in which he admits not being fond of psychological horror. The other is by Chris Moriarty and focuses on books about human survival.
“The Vindicator” by Matthew Hughes is the last story in his current cycle about Raffalon the thief. Raffalon is a mediocre burglar in the sort of fantasy city that has a Thieves’ Guild. For some reason a Vindicator (assassin) is after Raffalon, and the Vindicator’s Guild isn’t being helpful for calling it off. Raffalon hires a Discriminator (private investigator) and the truth turns out to be explosive.
A relatively rare Gardner Dozois story follows, “The Place of Bones.” A scholar and his companion discover the Dragonlands, where dragons go to die. More of a mood piece than a proper story.
“Lord Elgin at the Acropolis” by Minsoo Kang involves a police officer and writer meeting to consider the problem of a museum director who believes that one of the paintings in the museum is fake, despite no other evidence. Is he just crazy, or is there another explanation?
“Special Collections” by Kurt Fawver is a horror story about a library with a section you must never enter alone, which is the first rule. And then there’s the second rule….
David J. Skal reviews High-Rise for the film section, and compares it to the J.G. Ballard novel.
There’s the results of a contest for updating older science fiction works to today’s world. Including a “Dishonorable Mention” update of 1984.
“A Fine Balance” by Charlotte Ashley is set in a city where all disputes between the two major parties are settled by specially trained duelists. Except that one side doesn’t want to play by those rules any more. Very satisfying story.
“Passelande” by Robert Reed takes place in a depressing near future with electronic backups for people who can afford them. Backups who have their own feelings and motivations. This one grated on me, as I felt the characters had their motivations poorly explained/depicted.
“The Rhythm Man” by James Beamon is a variant on the legend about talented musicians selling their souls for skill or fame. A lot of set-up for one great scene at the end.
And the stories wrap up with “Merry Christmas from All of Us to All of You” by Sandra McDonald. It’s a dystopian tale of a gift-making community that ensures none of its children can truly escape. But perhaps there is a ray of hope?
There’s an “Easter egg” in the classified ads, and then an index of stories and features that appeared in 2016’s issues.
I liked “The Vindicator” and “A Fine Balance” best, though “The Cat Bell” was also quite entertaining. “Passendale” was the weakest story for me.
This magazine has consistently high quality stories and some nice cartoons; consider a print or Kindle subscription.
Book Review: Minnesota Vice by Ellen & Mary Kuhfeld
As I have mentioned before, Minnesota has many fine mystery and crime writers. Mary Kuhfeld is probably best known under the pen name Monica Ferris, under which she has written nineteen Betsy Devonshire Needlework Mysteries. (Thus the subtitle “Monica Ferris Presents” for these self-published books.) Ellen Kuhfeld is also an experienced mystery writer, and they collaborated on several stories for Alfred Hitchcock’s Mystery Magazine in the 1980s.
Of the ten stories in this collection, the first six are collaborations, and the first four are set in Hedeby, Minnesota, a largish town in the fictitious Hedeby County. The police detective team of Jack Hafner and Thor Nygaard is introduced in “An Ill Wind.” A sudden blizzard snows in the town, making Hafner and Nygaard the only officers able to respond to a report of murder. With all the outdoor clues buried under new-fallen snow, how will the detectives figure out which of the obvious suspects is guilty?
“Allergic to Death” takes place in a warmer season, as a man with lethal allergies apparently decides to take a walk in a pollen-laden garden. Simple enough, but one of the relatives insists on a cremation before an autopsy can be ordered. Honoring the wishes of the deceased, or covering up something more sinister?
“The Scales of Justice” concerns a traveling salesman who gets caught cheating at poker. Since the game itself was unlawful, the man can’t be arrested. Nygaard decides to treat the fellow to some traditional Norwegian hospitality. This story will be funnier if you’re familiar with Norwegian-American customs.
In “Night Light”, there’s a UFO, leading to suspicions that a murder and disappearance may have alien involvement. This is Hafner and Nygaard’s toughest case yet!
“Timely Psychiatric Intervention” features a government think tank that actually has a counselor handy to head off any of their scientists going mad. But the nature of McCain’s project may make Dr. Bach’s repeated attempts to help him moot.
In “A Specialist in Dragons”, Baron Halfdan’s daughter has been abducted by a dragon. He seeks the help of his local wizard, Wulfstan. Unfortunately, Wulfstan’s not up to the task of tracking a dragon, and a series of increasingly expensive specialists needs to be called in. Can Halla be rescued before the Baron runs out of gold?
The next four stories are solo efforts by Ellen Kuhfeld. “The Old Shell Game” concerns a museum curator that notices a valuable fossil has gone missing. It’s not anywhere on the grounds, but it’s impossible for this large item to have left the premises without being seen. How did it vanish?
“Thorolf and the Peacock” stars a Viking merchant (who is also the star of Ellen Kuhfeld’s book, Secret Murder) who is insulted by a flamboyant trader. Thorolf decides to treat the fellow to some traditional Norwegian hospitality. (In a slightly different manner than in “The Scales of Justice.”)
The next two stories were printed in speculative fiction magazines in the 2000s. “Dances with Werewolves” has the investigative team of Scott & Scott hired to determine if a man’s new girlfriend is a Were. This one contains a twist genre-savvy readers will spot quickly.
“Cycles of Violence” is a sequel to that tale, in which Bjorn the bartender must deal with a Wendigo invasion. It’s easier to do that when you’re a werebear!
The bane of self-published works, there are a few typos, including an error in the table of contents.
As a hodgepodge of previously un-reprinted stories, this volume may not satisfy mystery purists (even though most of them were printed in a mystery genre magazine.) That said, these are fun stories of which I liked “Allergic to Death” best. I felt “Dances with Werewolves” was the weakest, probably because I spotted the twist far too early.
Recommended to Minnesotans (especially mystery fans) and fans of the Monica Ferris books.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the authors to facilitate this review. No other compensation was requested or offered.
Magazine Review: Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine, January 1977 edited by Ellery Queen
Having enjoyed a recent issue of this magazine, I decided to root around for an older copy. This one was published in December 1976, but the cover date was a month ahead. Frederic Dannay (half of the “Ellery Queen” writing team) was still editor at this point, as he would be until 1981!
We open with “Jode’s Last Hunt” by Brian Garfield. Mr. Garfield is better known as the writer of Death Wish, which was turned into a hit movie starring Charles Bronson. This story, his first in EQMM, stars Sheriff Jode, who was a big hero in his Arizona county when he first started. But that was a couple of decades ago, and between competent policing and a naturally low crime rate, Jode hasn’t hit the headlines in years. When a former rodeo and movie star turns eco-terrorist, the near-retirement sheriff sees one last chance at fame. This one was collected in Great Tales of Mystery and Suspense in 1985.
“The Final Twist” by William Bankier is set at a small advertising firm where the boss is a bad person who managed to offend each of his workers individually and as a group. His employees decide he needs to die, but they want to make it look like suicide. How can they best use their skills to this end? This one was turned into an episode of Alfred Hitchcock Presents in 1986.
1976 was the year of the Bicentennial, the 200th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence. Thanks to that, there was a huge market for stories set during the American Revolution and 1776 in particular. Fitting in one last story on the theme for the year is “The Spirit of the ’76” by Lillian de la Torre. It details a bit of secret history when Benjamin Franklin’s grandson is kidnapped and Dr. Sam: Johnson is tapped to track the lad down, with the help of faithful Boswell, of course. The story perhaps is too eager to have Mr. Boswell praise the inventive American, especially given the political situation. This one was collected in The Exploits of Dr. Sam: Johnson, Detector in 1987.
“To Be Continued” by Barbara Callahan is about a young soap opera fan who discovers that she has an unexpected connection with one of the characters. There’s a surprisingly sympathetic portrayal of a gay man for the time period, but the treatment of mental illness may strike some readers poorly. I did not find any reprints of this one.
“C as in Crooked” by Lawrence Treat is a police procedural starring Detective Mitch Taylor. He’s assigned to look into a burglary involving a very rich and important man (which is why a homicide detective is working a burglary case.) Mitch quickly notices that the person in charge of security for that and several other robbed homes is an ex-police officer. Personal problems for both Mitch and his boss delay the investigation until the next morning, when it has become a murder case. Mitch cracks the case, but he may not get the credit. I did not find any reprints of this one.
“‘Twas the Plight Before Christmas” by Hershel Cozine is a poem parodying the famous A Visit from Saint Nicholas and has Santa Claus being murdered by Ebenezer Scrooge. Don’t worry, kids, there’s a happy ending.
There are two “Department of First Stories” (authors being professionally published for the first time) entries in this issue. “After the Storm” by L.G. Kerrigan is a short piece about a murder during a rainstorm. It’s vivid but slight. “A Pair of Gloves” by Richard E. Hutton is a chiller about a man trying to buy a Christmas present despite the presence of a downer street person who seems to have a grudge against the store. The ending is telegraphed. Neither seems to have been reprinted.
Four brief columns follow, two of book reviews (one blatantly pushing items for sale by the magazine’s publisher), one of movie reviews (The Seven-Per-Cent Solution and Marathon Man are highlighted) and a short interview with Dick Francis, former jockey and famous for his racing-related mysteries.
“With More Homage to Saki” by Isak Romun is a short tale of a wealthy gourmet who will do anything to keep his personal chef working for him, up to and including blackmail. But the chef has prepared his own delicious dilemma. Foodies will enjoy this one best, I think. Another I cannot find a reprint of.
Next up is from “The Department of Second Stories”, where EQMM also bought the author’s second effort. “The Thumbtack Puzzle” by Robert C. Schweik features Professor of Bibliography Paul Engle. During a talk the professor is giving, the narrator (his bookstore-owning friend) discovers that a visiting chemist’s work has been tampered with, and perhaps stolen. There’s only a handful of viable suspects, but which, and can it be determined with only a thumbtack as a clue? The solution hinges on the peculiarities of German typewriters. No reprint here, either.
“Raffles and the Shere Khan Pouch” by Barry Perowne has the gentleman thief (and devoted cricket player) and his sidekick Bunny visiting India. There they run into Rudyard Kipling and Madame Blavatsky while attempting to steal rubies. This is made more complicated by a British diplomatic pouch having gone missing, making the authorities more alert. There’s perhaps a bit too much coincidence for the story to be plausible, and the epilogue spells out who Kipling is for particularly obtuse readers, but Raffles is always a delight. This story was reprinted in Raffles of the M.C.C. in 1979.
“Please Don’t Help the Bear” by Ron Goulart is the sad tale of a Hollywood animator with a fur allergy and a penchant for another man’s wife. Mr. Goulart is perhaps better known for his science fiction, but mostly for his humor, though this time it’s gallows humor. The narrator is his “Adman” character who has a habit of meeting murderers and murder victims and never saving one. This story may or may not be reprinted in Adam and Eve on a Raft: Mystery Stories published in 2001.
“Etiquette for Dying” by Celia Fremlin concerns a woman whose social climber husband has taken ill at a dinner party whose hostess is well above their class. Is he just rudely drunk or is there something more sinister going on? This one is reprinted in A Lovely Day to Die and Other Stories (1984).
And finally, we have a story by prolific author Edward D. Hoch, “The Problem of the Christmas Steeple.” It’s a Dr. Sam Hawthorne story, as the retired physician remembers the winter of 1925. A parson is found stabbed to death in a steeple, the only suspect being the “gypsy” chief found in the steeple with him. But due to physical infirmity, that suspect could not have committed the murder. The treatment of “gypsies” may rankle modern readers, but it’s a story written in the 1970s about the 1920s. This story was reprinted in Diagnosis: Impossible: The Problems of Dr. Sam Hawthorne (1996).
There are also a couple of limericks by D.R. Bensen, typical of the genre.
This is overall a good issue, with some fine writers. You can try combing garage sales, but you might have better luck contacting other collectors.
And now, an audio adaptation of “The Problem of the Christmas Steeple”:
Quick recap: When teen genius detective Shin’ichi Kudou (Jimmy Kudo in the American edition) is targeted by a mysterious criminal organization, the experimental poison used shrinks him to child size rather than killing him. Assuming the identity of Conan Edogawa, the pint-sized sleuth moves in with incompetent private eye Kogoro Mouri (Richard Moore) and his daughter Ran (Rachel), who is Shin’ichi’s love interest. Now Conan solves mysteries, but must be more clever in how he lets the police know whodunit, as his true identity and capabilities must remain secret.
In the volume to hand, #59, the Rena Mizunashi subplot has a shocking conclusion…at least for now. The Black Organization seems to be fooled, but for how long and at what cost?
Then Kogoro’s ex-wife Eri (Eva) keeps an appointment at the hairdresser’s, only to have the beautician’s ex-boyfriend turn up dead nearby. Conan must break a seemingly perfect alibi. There’s another near-miss for Eri and Kogoro getting back together.
The “Centipede” case follows, as two families’ sons are murdered in bizarre fashion, each with a centipede dropped near the corpse. The parents initially suspect each other due to a long-standing feud, and Kogoro and Osakan teen detective Heiji (Harley) are called in on opposite sides. Heiji and Conan quickly ally as more murders happen according to a pattern inspired by famous samurai Lord Shingen and his battle motto, “Fuurinkazan.”
This case also introduces a new police character, Kansuke Yamato of Nagano. He’s crippled and scarred from an avalanche, which has the advantage of making him very distinctive and unlikely to be confused with the many other cops in this series. He independently works out the identity of the killer, but the younger detectives are still very useful.
The volume concludes with Eisuke, Rena’s brother, returning to school and being talked into a karaoke party. Conan spots an FBI agent tailing Eisuke, but when the agent then turns up dead, is Eisuke the killer, or is it the Black Organization…or someone with no connection to that case? You’ll need to wait for the next volume to find out!
As always, the art is decent, and the writing fun. I really appreciated that the new police detective was competent and didn’t need to be handheld by Conan as so many of the others do. The only real flaw is that the first chapter depends so heavily on previous knowledge of the Rena subplot that it’s likely to be confusing to someone who picked up the book randomly.
The U.S. release is still years behind Japan, so it may be a while before we learn the next parts of the subplots.
Book Review: The Four False Weapons by John Dickson Carr
Richard Curtis, junior partner at the law firm of Curtis, Hunt, D’Arcy & Curtis, is beginning to regret his career choice. The office-bound life of a solicitor is dreadfully dull for a young man that longs for adventure and secret missions! Just as he is about to succumb to utter boredom, Mr. Hunt, the acting senior partner, calls Richard in for a conference. It seems that Ralph Douglas, a wealthy young client of the firm, has noticed odd things going on at a villa near Paris that he rents but does not live at. It’s probably nothing important, but can Richard dash across the Channel to check in with Mr. Douglas?
As it happens, Ralph is in a bit of a delicate situation between his fiancee Magda Toller, her overprotective mother, and his ex-lover Rose Clonec. The villa in question was where he put up La Clonec while they were together; it’s supposed to be shut up tight, but someone’s been there recently and turned on the electricity and laid in a supply of champagne. Ralph can’t contact Rose directly to ask if she’s responsible without arousing the suspicions of Mama Toller.
When the men drive out to the villa, they find a maid who claims that Ralph was there last night (he claims he wasn’t.) Worse, they find the corpse of Ms. Clonec in an upstairs bedroom. There are multiple potential murder weapons in the room, but are any of them what actually caused her death? If Ralph’s telling the truth, then it’s a pretty sweet frame job, but who would do this, and why? Good thing famous police detective Bencolin has been called out of retirement for this one last case!
John Dickson Carr (1906-1977) was considered a master of the “locked room” mystery, where a crime seems impossible, but this one (the fifth and last Bencolin book) isn’t so much a locked room, as one with too many and contradictory clues that Bencolin must sift through. At one point early on, he declares that he knows who done it, but not why or how–a couple of chapters later, new evidence turns it upside down, and now he claims to know why and how, but no longer who!
While the puzzle pieces are being assembled, Richard tries to act in the best interests of his client while falling in love with Magda. This romance subplot is possibly the least necessary element of the book, and comes across rushed and forced. Much more fun are the antics of newspaper reporter and amateur sleuth Jean-Baptiste Robinson, who keeps guessing almost right. (He also sports a Hitler mustache, which in 1937 was just eccentric, but a couple of years later would have gotten him lynched.)
The climax is a high-stakes card game where Richard must play Basset, a lost game of kings, to reveal the final clue Bencolin needs to prove who murdered Rose Clonec. This ramps up the suspense considerably as Richard doesn’t know whether he needs to win or lose to achieve the detective’s goal.
This isn’t Carr’s best work, but is a fun, light read; worth looking up at your local library if you enjoy older mysteries.
Book Review: The Black Bat #1: Brand of the Black Bat & Murder Calls the Black Bat by Norman Daniels (writing as G. Wayman Jones)
Tony Quinn was a handsome, wealthy and highly competent district attorney until the day of Oliver Snate’s trial. This time he had proof of the gangster’s illegal activities, actual recordings of Snate openly talking about his crimes. But Snate had a plan to destroy the evidence. Out-of-town criminals infiltrated the courtroom, and when the recordings were brought out of their protective cover, the thugs caused a riot. One of them hurled a bottle of vitriol on the recordings, incidentally also hitting D.A. Quinn, who had moved to protect the evidence.
The acid hit Tony’s face, horribly scarring him, and more importantly, rendering him blind! With the key evidence destroyed and a less effective prosecutor filling in, Snate’s slick lawyer was able to get the case dismissed. Without his sight, Mr. Quinn thought his career was over, and the medical experts told him there was nothing they could do. Tony became a hermit, aided only by his manservant “Silk” Kirby, a former conman who’d reformed to help Tony against an earlier assassination attempt.
Then a mysterious woman arrived, who told Tony that if he secretly went to a certain town in Illinois, there was one doctor that could cure his blindness. After a period of recovery, not only could Tony Quinn see again, but he now possessed the ability to see in the dark! Remembering how Snate had mocked him as “blind as a bat”, Tony decided to conceal his new abilities, and operate as the mysterious vigilante, the Black Bat.
In one of those interesting coincidences comic book history is littered with, the Black Bat first appeared in Black Book Detective about the same month that Batman first appeared in Detective Comics. And it very much was a coincidence–the pulp character was called “the Tiger” in the original draft, from the striped facial scars. But the publisher of Black Book Detective wanted him to be the lead character in that magazine, so he was rewritten into a darker mode, drawing on much the same cultural influences that Bob Kane and Bill Finger used to create Batman.
The two very similar characters brought about mutual threats of lawsuit–but the companies settled on an agreement that Batman would appear in comics only, while the Black Bat would stick to prose. We’ll get back to that later.
Back in the story, Oliver Snate has graduated to making armored cars vanish on a regular basis. He’s smart, but not that smart, so the Black Bat suspects a criminal mastermind at work. The Black Bat begins his plan by interfering with a bank robbery. A ex-boxer named Jack “Butch” O’Leary and the mystery girl, Carol Baldwin, get caught up in this and join the Black Bat’s team. The Black Bat also makes an enemy of Detective Sergeant McGrath, an honest policeman who wants to arrest the vigilante for breaking the law. McGrath catches on to the connection between the Black Bat and Tony Quinn quickly, but is never able to prove they’re the same person. (Police Commissioner Warner also suspects, but is much less motivated to catch the Bat.)
It turns out that Carol’s father was a police officer who’d been blinded by Oliver Snate in a different way some years before. Dying, he convinced Dr. Harrington, a brilliant surgeon living in obscurity for reasons never discussed, to transplant his intact corneas and other vital bits into Tony Quinn’s eyes. (Dr. Harrington is declared dead offstage at the beginning of the second story, so we never follow up on him.) Carol and Tony are strongly affectionate towards each other, though they both know romance is out of the question.
Now that all the pieces are in place, it’s time to run Snate to earth, and expose the true villain behind him.
Our heroes are pretty cold-blooded about killing; Tony and Silk don’t hesitate to shoot criminals even before they become vigilantes, and the team racks up quite a body count by the end. Perhaps the most brutal moment is when the Black Bat straight up murders a parked getaway driver so that bank robbers will be forced to use a car he’s gimmicked to record their voices.
The Black Bat’s double life is a recurring problem; he must often cut investigations short and hurry home so that poor, blind Tony Quinn can be seen to still be blind and most certainly not running around in a hood and cape.
Carol’s backstory has her be an effective solo operator until she joins the team, at which point she never takes initiative any more, just doing whatever the Black Bat assigns. Yes, she does get into peril a lot and need to be saved, but Silk and Butch are about equally peril-prone.
In the second story, several elite jewelry emporiums discover that large portions of their stock have turned counterfeit, seemingly overnight. One owner is apparently driven to suicide, while another consults Tony Quinn (who used to be his lawyer before being elected district attorney) before apparently driving off a cliff in an exploding automobile. When a hitman shows up to kill Tony, he realizes that the crooks behind this bizarre series of events must think he knows more about what’s going on than he really does. Time to become the Black Bat!
Freed of having to do a lot of set-up, this story is more of an action-mystery with plenty of suspects. There’s a nasty torture scene, though the cover switches Silk with Carol for the equivalent peril. The bad guys’ major weak point turns out to be that the field leader of the thieves is obviously planning to betray his boss just as soon as he has the loot. There’s some ethnic stereotyping.
One neat bit that comes up is that Tony’s scars make the Black Bat not be a master of disguise. He can disguise himself a bit, but he’s no man of a thousand faces, leaving that to the clever Silk.
Now, remember that deal I mentioned a few paragraphs ago? Eventually, the publisher of Black Bat wanted to adapt some of the magazine stories to comic book form. But they couldn’t use the name “Black Bat,” so he was changed to the Owl. Oops, by the time the art was finished, someone had started publishing another superhero named “the Owl.” So the script was quickly changed by Raymond Thayer to call the main character “the Mask.” “The Mask Strikes” from Exciting Comics #1 is the first half of “Brand of the Black Bat” with a few names changed, and the hero wearing a noticeably bird-themed hood. Very compact art that gets a lot done in a few pages.
The Black Bat’s origin went on to inspire comic book characters Dr. Mid-Nite and Two-Face. Batman-related character Cassandra Cain took up the name Black Bat for a few issues before a reboot made her vanish (the latest version of her is now called “Orphan”), and the Tony Quinn Black Bat finally got to appear in comics in a series from Dynamite.
Recommended for pulp fans, and fans of two-fisted vigilantes who don’t pull punches when dealing with criminals.
Comic Book Review: Noble Causes Archives, Vol. 1 written by Jay Faerber
Liz Donnelly is nervous about meeting her future in-laws. After all, she’s just a normal bookstore manager, and they’re the Noble Family, celebrity superheroes, beloved across the world. Her fiance Race Noble is nice enough, but Liz soon learns that behind the glitzy facade, the Noble family has severe problems that are tearing them apart. When tragedy strikes, it could be the ending of Liz’s world, if not everyone’s.
This Image Comics offering was a series of miniseries before getting approved for an ongoing (with a soft reset.) It takes the soap opera aspects of modern superhero comics, and the idea of superheroes as celebrities, and runs with it. Indeed, the soap opera is so central that it’s several issues before we see one of the family do something that matches the “hero” part of the genre.
At the beginning, the family consists of “Doc” Noble, an inventor/adventurer who has retreated into his laboratory more and more as the years have gone by, rather than interact with his brood; his wife Gaia, a nature mage from another dimension who craved the celebrity lifestyle and has crafted the family’s public image; Icarus, Doc’s robot assistant, who considers himself the dutiful son; Rusty, who recently suffered an “accident” that required transplanting his brain into a robotic body; Celeste, Rusty’s gold digger wife, who was unfaithful to him even before he became all metal; Race, a super-speedster who has the best emotional balance of the crew; Krennick, Race’s best buddy and son of family enemy Draconis, who has an unrequited thing for; Zephyr, only daughter and a rebellious teenager whose promiscuity has gotten out of hand; and Frost, Gaia’s son by a brief affair, who officially does not exist, and has been sleeping with Celeste.
Liz’s marriage to Race helps precipitate a series of events that bring to light several family secrets and relationship crises. The series is really good at issue-ending cliffhangers.
This black and white reprint volume covers up to issue #12 of the ongoing, and the resolution of the Zephyr pregnancy plotline. There were a number of back-up stories that flashed back to events before Liz met the family; instead of being bundled with the main stories of each issue they were published in, they have been placed at the end of the volume. These stories explain some motivations and sometimes make the characters’ actions more sympathetic.
Content warnings: There’s a fairly gory scene early on, a lot of talk about sex (and some near-sex scenes) and some rather disturbing implications in the backstory. I’d say senior high school and up for readership.
Many of the characters are not particularly likable. (When Doc suddenly starts being a somewhat better husband and father, Gaia worries that he’s terminally ill.) But there are enough of them that are sympathetic or enjoyable to keep reading.
The art is by a number of different creators, mostly in the decent to acceptable range.
Recommended to comic book fans who are really into the soap opera aspect.
Magazine Review: The Saturday Evening Post 6/10/61 edited by Ben Hibbs
The Saturday Evening Post ran weekly from 1897-1963; after several format changes, it is now published six times a year. The Post was well known for its lavish illustrations and a combination of current event articles and short stories by popular writers. I got this issue from the month of my birth as an early birthday present. At the time, this magazine was printed in the broadsheet format, which is too large for my scanner–thus the truncated cover image showing only a part of Amos Spewell’s painting of tourists in Venice.
To entice potential customers at newsstands, the Post front-loaded the illustrations in spreads at the front of the magazine, and each of the articles and stories continued in the word-heavy back pages interspersed with a few cartoons. There were also many large illustrated advertisements–one for tampons is notable for not telling the reader what the product is, showing the product or saying what it’s used for exactly; if I didn’t know from the name of the product, I’d assume it’s some kind of skin cleanser or deodorant.
The Post was also known for having a staunchly conservative editorial stance, and this is on full display in an editorial expressing relief that leftist thought was vanishing from college campuses and conservatism was on the rise. “Of course, the battle isn’t over. Queer characters still appear on college campuses sponsored by ‘liberal’ groups.” Oh, if only they knew!
In the lively letters to the editor section, comments on an article about Bobby Darrin reveal changes in our pop culture, with people being shocked or pleased that he was willing to share personal opinions with the press even if they didn’t match the public’s desired stance. One letter writer asked why an article on “Presidents in Retirement” did not include FDR. The editor waggishly replies that the place that man retired to is not on the reporter’s regular beat. There’s also a couple of letters on segregation, responding negatively to a previous letter writer’s suggestion that since Southerners didn’t go to Northern states to demand segregation, Northerners should reciprocate about desegregation.
Let’s look at the contents.
“The White House Insiders” by Stewart Alsop is a look at President Kennedy’s political staffers (all men, all white-one had a black deputy) and how they helped him keep on top of what was happening in the country and the world. It goes into detail about JFK’s management style. The only top staff name most younger readers are likely to recognize is Arthur Schlesinger Jr., but Henry Kissinger is briefly mentioned as a second-stringer.
“Death of a Demon” by Rex Stout is part one of three of a Nero Wolfe mystery novella. The sedentary detective is briefly engaged by a woman who wants to show him the gun she will not use to shoot her husband. That’s…kind of suspicious, and when the husband turns up dead from a bullet wound, some questions are raised. Archie Goodwin, Wolfe’s leg man, is pretty sure the woman didn’t do it, but there are gaping holes in her story. It’s certainly an intriguing beginning! Happily, this story was included in Homicide Trinity by Rex Stout, which you can probably get through interlibrary loan.
“How the Doctors Saved Chicago’s Burned Children” by Alice Lake is a look at how St. Anne’s Hospital dealt with the victims of a fire at Our Lady of the Angels School in 1958. 95 people died immediately or in the aftermath, but this story concentrates on the survivors. Part of the credit for St. Anne’s quick and organized response goes to disaster preparedness they had undertaken after a fire some years before had caught the hospital unprepared for multiple victims. There are details of the treatment s used and updates on a couple of the survivors as of mid-1961. One of the treatments tried was using blood transfusions from recovering adult burn victims in the hope that their blood had antigens against “burn toxin.” (From the little I could find, research into this treatment has shown scant evidence of effectiveness.) For more on the fire, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Our_Lady_of_the_Angels_School_fire
“Handsome Samaritan” by Phyllis Duganne is a story about an airline pilot driving to vacation in Florida when he stops to help some stranded motorists. One of them is a very pretty woman, but he’s supposed to be meeting his fiancee. The pilot comes to realize he is much more compatible with this new woman who is more interested in who he is than who she can make him become. I found this story uncomfortable, and skimmed to the end.
“The Poacher” by Gene Coghlan, set in Depression-era North Dakota, has two brothers growing up on an isolated farm, and using traps to earn a little pocket money. One brother is laid up with a broken leg, and the protagonist takes advantage of this to claim that a fur animal was caught in one of his traps, rather than his brother’s. Presumably he learned a valuable lesson about life, but the conclusion pages are missing from my copy. Unfortunately, Mr. Coghlan doesn’t seem to have any books in print.
“The Case of the Comical Banker” by Harold H. Martin, profiles Mills Bee Lane, Jr., then president of the Citizens & Southern National Bank in Atlanta, Georgia. Known for a jovial style (unlike the stuffy conservatism usually associated with bankers of the period), his business acumen turned the C&S into the largest bank in the South. You may be more familiar with his nephew, Mills Bee Lane III, who became a famous boxing referee and TV judge. Lane, Jr. was credited in the article for jumpstarting tobacco farming in the Atlanta area when cotton took a dive in the market.
“The Meaning of the Eichmann Trial” by T.S. Matthews was published about halfway through the war crimes trial of Adolf Eichmann. (He was found guilty and hanged.) The article talks a lot about the trial conditions and the thoroughness of the Israeli court system. “Israel means to show the world that, in the British phrase, ‘justice is not only done but seen to have been done.” It also talks about the character of Israel as a country, and its people. The trial took place in a newly built suburb of Jerusalem, because at that time the Old City was in the hands of Jordan. This is a very moving article, and I think the best in the issue.
“Cop with Camera Eyes” by Thomas Walsh features a police detective with “photographic memory”, if he sees something, and it’s important to him at a later time, he will remember it clearly. It triggers when he notices the same person in the crowd three times during a date he’s having with his new neighbor. After safely returning his date home, The cop ambushes this tail. Surprise! It’s a federal agent! Seems the attractive foreign lady is suspected of being a Communist spy. Reluctantly, the cop agrees to keep an eye on the girl he has come to adore, but then she vanishes–and for the first time, the cop’s memory fails him at a critical moment. Can he crack the case before innocents are killed? It’s a pretty good story; I don’t know if it’s ever been reprinted, but Mr. Walsh’s Nightmare in Manhattan is considered a superior mystery novel and that you can find.
“Is Nature Getting Neurotic?” by Corey Ford is a humor piece about how over-complicated gardening and landscaping have become, requiring the homeowner to employ multiple specialists and expensive treatments just to keep the lawn alive.
“In the Best Interest of the Service” by Walt Grove takes us inside an Air Force base. A major must make a difficult decision because of the need for unit cohesiveness. A rescue chopper pilot is being accused of cowardice by one of his crew members. This is complicated by the officer being a Negro, and the crew member being a white man from the Deep South and the type of person who nowadays would be decrying “political correctness.” He doesn’t mean any harm by the N-word, he claims, so why shouldn’t he use it? But that does raise the stink of possible racism. Oh, and the chopper pilot is the major’s best friend on the base, so there may be the question of favoritism. Who will be getting transferred out? The resolution to the situation may be a little too convenient, but is satisfying, and inspires the major to take some steps in his personal life he’s put off too long. Mr. Grove wrote several action books about pilots, but it doesn’t appear any are currently in print.
“Comeback of the Giant Turtle” by Bern Keating is about efforts to increase the population of the green sea turtle (so called because of its distinctive green fat deposits inside the shell) in the Caribbean. Despite these and other preservation efforts, the green sea turtle remains an endangered species.
And finally, “The Big Swindle” by Clarence Budington Kelland is part 5 of 6. Twins Pet and Pete Du Chillon have finally come of age, and are attempting to make sense of what their guardian, Mortimer Norton, has done with the family company. It seems all sorts of shady shenanigans have been going on! The twins have some sort of scheme to expose the truth, involving a phony foreign prince and double-bluffing the man who runs security for Du Chillon Industries. This installment suffers from coming in the middle of the story, but I think it’s also a pretty bad story. Pet and Pete, as well as their beloved grandmother, are the sort of people who the author tries hard to convince us are very witty, but come off snide instead. The funniest bit for me was one of the supporting characters denying the possibility of a “twins threesome” in such a way as to make me think he’s thought waay too much about the topic (and also never mentioning sex because this is a family magazine.) Mr. Kelland is largely forgotten, but once was popular enough that Harlan Ellison called him out by name for lowering the tastes of the American public.
There’s also short poems (amusing but forgettable), jokes and cartoons.
This was a fun look back at a moment in time just before I was born. Copies of the Post in bad condition can be found relatively cheaply; issues in excellent condition, or with stories by top authors, will set you back considerably more money. Also, you can visit the website of the current magazine: http://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/